America still doesn't know how to talk about Kamala Harris

CNN Politics 1 week ago

Kamala Harris' campaign wasn't perfect -- but the context of her candidacy shouldn't be ignored, either.

The California Democrat, who on Tuesday bowed out of the 2020 race for the White House, struggled to maintain a coherent vision on the campaign trail and internal turmoil permeated her camp. But scrutiny of just those mistakes glosses over the specific histories that have shaped the woman who was the only black female candidate in the race and the uneven standards that had a hand in knocking her out of it.

While Barack Obama succeeded in getting elected as America's first black president and Hillary Clinton became the first woman to win the first major party presidential nomination, it's obvious both African Americans and women are underrepresented in US politics (and board rooms and other upper echelons of power). It's not just a coincidence -- there are very real biases that work against minorities and women.

    Those biases and cultural complexities mean a record of achievement that could lift a white man's candidacy -- a career as a strong law enforcement officer -- could pull down a black woman.

    Her most obvious demerit was her career as a prosecutor, first as San Francisco's district attorney and then as the state's attorney general. The narrative became, simply: Kamala's a cop.

    And yet, black Americans' relationship with the criminal justice system can't be captured so easily. As The Atlantic's Peter Beinart explains: "What (Harris' critics) didn't do nearly enough was ask whether Harris, as a black woman, could have adopted non-punitive crime policies 10 or 15 years ago and become a city district attorney and state attorney general in the first place," given that "perceived softness on crime was particularly perilous for black politicians."

    This bind stretches back even further. In his 2017 book "Locking Up Our Own: Crime and Punishment in Black America," the Yale Law School professor and former public defender James Forman Jr. chronicles not only the fact that black politicians in the 1970s embraced tough-on-crime policies but also why.

    "(Black leaders) want more police, more prisons, better jobs, better schools, better parks. They want the whole thing, all of the above. Instead, they get one of the above, which is law enforcement," Forman told NPR, describing the "pressure-cooker environment" that existed in the years before anyone knew of the singular damage America's drug war would inflict on black communities.

    This isn't to excuse the flawed decisions Harris has made in the past, especially those, such as her advocacy for anti-truancy laws (which she has apologized for), that wrought disproportionate harm on marginalized communities. Neither is it to suggest that she shouldn't have faced hard scrutiny in, of all environments, a presidential contest.

    Rather, it's to underscore that context is key. A better understanding of the political foundation that has influenced Harris offers valuable insight into the dueling interests she had to contend with as a top-tier Democratic candidate. And that's to say nothing of the pernicious alchemy of racism and sexism she navigated compared with some of her rivals. ("Success within the system was still a laudable act of subversiveness -- whether as an investment banker, a corporate lawyer or a district attorney," The Washington Post's Robin Givhan recently wrote of Harris' time as an undergraduate at Howard University.)

    And: The Democratic pool, once lauded for its unprecedented diversity, is now all the worse for this fundamental lack of rigor. As my CNN colleague MJ Lee tweeted on Tuesday: "Kamala Harris' campaign was historic -- a black and South Asian female candidate whose potential seemed sky high early on," she wrote. "Her dropping out means that every candidate that's qualified so far for the next debate is white: Biden, Buttigieg, Klobuchar, Sanders, Steyer and Warren."

      Or as the journalist Mythili Sampathkumar put it: "Personal political disagreements aside: it was/is profound to have seen a Tamil girl be so comfortable in all her cultures and run for president."

      Looking ahead, perhaps the more meaningful thing to do isn't to enumerate Harris' missteps; it's to remember that this country still isn't prepared to talk honestly about certain black experiences.


      Source link
      Read also:
      CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
      US Energy Secretary Rick Perry said Friday he "didn't see a problem" with being asked by President Donald Trump to speak with Rudy Giuliani about matters involving Ukraine.
      CNN › Politics › 2 months ago
      On a recent brisk fall night in the shadow of a water tower in Ankeny, Iowa, Kamala Harris bounded on stage to LL Cool J's "Mama Said Knock You Out."
      CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
      Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris said Friday that she'd skip the "Second Step Presidential Justice Forum" at Benedict College in South Carolina -- setting off President Donald Trump's ire when she said that it was because he received an...
      CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
      Twitter told Sen. Kamala Harris that it would not suspend President Donald Trump's account despite her urging the company to do so, according to a copy of a letter the company sent to the Harris presidential campaign.
      CNN › Entertainment › 2 months ago
      For 'Breaking Bad' and 'Downton Abbey,' 'the end' wasn't, as studios increasingly turn to revivals after series finales
      CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
      Former White House chief of staff John Kelly said that before he left the White House last year, he warned President Donald Trump not to hire a replacement who wouldn't tell him the truth or that he would be impeached, the Washington Examiner reported...
      The Independent › Opinions › 1 week ago
      This isn't a defense of Kamala Harris as a politician, or her record. It's a defense of Kamala Harris as a human being
      CNN › Politics › 2 months ago
      For Lev Parnas and Igor Fruman, becoming powerful Republican donors didn't take very long.
      CNN › Politics › 3 hours ago
      Kamala Harris' abrupt departure from the 2020 presidential field means she appears less in the public space. She isn't out on the campaign trail. Her name appears in fewer stories.
      The Inquisitr › Politics › 1 week ago
      Kamala Harris will reportedly be dropping out of the presidential election today, according to The Atlantic staff writer Edward-Isaac Dovere. Kamala Harris Reportedly Drops Out Of Democratic Primary Race is an article from: The Inquisitr Click here to...
      Sign In

      Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

      Continue with Google
      OR