After defeating menthol ban, Sharpton sought out by former foes

Politico Politics 1 week ago

After losing a battle with Rev. Al Sharpton to ban the sale of menthol cigarettes citywide, the NAACP’s Hazel Dukes and Rev. Kirsten John Foy have asked him to join an effort to craft new legislation that addresses the same criminal justice concerns Sharpton has been vying for all along.

Sharpton agreed to join the group, but in an interview with POLITICO, he said he wishes the effort had happened sooner.

Story Continued Below

“They want to work out the criminal justice element, but an element to what bill?” he said Wednesday. “The better question is: if they’re willing to work on criminal justice now, what was their objection all along?”

Sharpton has voiced opposition to the bill for months over concerns that a ban on the sale of menthols will spur the growth of black market cigarette sales and increase interactions between black smokers and police. Eric Garner, who was killed at the hands of the NYPD, was first approached by officers for selling loose cigarettes illegally.

The bill’s demise, first reported by POLITICO, is a testament to Sharpton’s political sway in a city where many Council members, including Speaker Corey Johnson, are likely to run for new gigs when their terms are up in 2021.

The menthol ban had a veto-proof majority of 37 sponsors, as well as the backing of Dukes, Foy, public health officials and Mayor Bill de Blasio. But Johnson, echoing Sharpton’s objections, maintained he had concerns with criminalizing menthol smokers who are predominantly African-American and the bill never got out of the health committee, chaired by Council Member Mark Levine.

In a letter obtained by POLITICO, Foy, Dukes and Sharpton ask Johnson and Council Member Fernando Cabrera to kill the already abandoned bill, Intro. 1345, and establish a group to draft a new version.

“It is unjust to expect communities of color to choose between greater public health protections and basic civil rights,” the letter reads. “We do not accept the premise that we must choose between the two, that these interests are mutually exclusive nor that this debate is zero sum.”

Sharpton said the last-ditch effort to revitalize the ban shows “there’s been opposition all along.”

Police officers are required to arrest individuals selling loose cigarettes after a certain number of summonses have been issued, Sharpton said, adding an acceptable bill would aim to change those protocols.

“I want to see that there’s a bill that doesn’t put people at risk,” he said.

The fight over the bill cast Sharpton against political leaders like former mayor David Dinkins, Rep. Gregory Meeks and First Lady Chirlane McCray, who all backed the ban.

The divisions turned nasty in recent weeks. Sharpton’s group, the National Action Network, has taken money in the past from tobacco giant R.J. Reynolds. When the bill died, Assemblywoman Rodneyse Bichotte took to Twitter, saying Sharpton had been “bought by tobacco companies” and asked the state attorney general to investigate.

Sharpton said the donations had nothing to do with his position on criminal justice.

“We get money from big tobacco, we get money from Bloomberg [for anti-tobacco initiatives],” he told POLITICO. "It’s down to criminal justice”

Foy — a menthol smoker who supported the ban citing public health risks for black and brown New Yorkers — said the divisive remarks from Bichotte were part of the catalyst to join forces with Sharpton, a long-time ally.

He said the idea was “to get through this issue in a collaborative way, in a productive way, in a context of good faith.”

The speaker’s office said it would continue to work through issues surrounding the bill.

“This issue is a priority for Speaker Johnson,” spokesperson Jacob Tugendrajch said. “The Council takes the feedback from these leaders seriously and will continue to work with them to improve the health and safety of New Yorkers.”

Source link
Read also:
New York Post › Opinions › 2 weeks ago
The City Council voted 42-2 Tuesday to ban flavored e-cigarettes, including menthol — but it’s refraining from banning regular menthol cigs, apparently at the behest of the Rev. Al Sharpton. The perverse result is that anyone looking to legally...
New York Post › 2 weeks ago
When the Rev. Al Sharpton calls, City Council Speaker Corey Johnson apparently listens. A bill to ban menthol-cigarette sales in the city has garnered overwhelming support in the council, yet Johnson refuses to bring it to a vote on the floor...
New York Post › 1 month ago
The mothers of Eric Garner and Trayvon Martin want to snuff out a city proposal to outlaw menthol-flavored cigarettes, worrying that such a ban would fuel a menthol black market leading to more deadly “stop and frisk” encounters between police and...
New York Post › Politics › 1 month ago
Michael Bloomberg gave the Rev. Al Sharpton the heads up Thursday that he was yet again eyeing a White House run in 2020, the civil rights activist told The Post. “I get a sense that Mike is going all the way in,” Sharpton said in an interview...
New York Post › 0 month ago
He’s the million-dollar minister. The Rev. Al Sharpton raked in $1,046,948 from his own charity last year, according to National Action Network’s latest tax filings obtained by The Post. Sharpton got a $324,000 salary — 32% higher than his 2017...
USA Today › 3 weeks ago
Several of the Democratic hopefuls for president joined Rev. Al Sharpton for a breakfast Thursday, hosted by Sharpton's own National Action Network. (Nov. 21)
HuffPost › 1 month ago
Anti-smoking activists are using the increased attention on vaping to target menthol cigarettes, but some African Americans say menthol cigarette bans wi...
Axios › Politics › 1 month ago
The Trump administration plans to finalize a ban on almost all flavored vaping products, with exemptions only for tobacco and menthol flavors, according to sources familiar with the plan. An announcement is expected next week.Why it matters...
The Boston Globe › 1 month ago
Hundreds of convenience stores plan to close midday on Wednesday as store owners rally to oppose a proposed ban on menthol cigarettes and to “demonstrate the critical role they play providing vital resources to communities,” organizers said.
The Wall Street Journal › Politics › 1 month ago
The Food and Drug Administration is moving forward on a ban of all e-cigarettes other than those that taste like tobacco and menthol, citing new data on the vaping flavors most popular among teenagers.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google