DACA heads to Supreme Court and all eyes are on Chief Justice John Roberts

Fox News Politics 3 weeks ago
The president signed an executive order to end DACA in 2017, as he believes it gives the president 'extraordinary powers'.

The Supreme Court on Tuesday is set to take up the Trump administration’s plan to end protections that shield about 660,000 immigrants from deportation, and legal experts say all eyes will be on the likely tie-breaker Chief Justice John Roberts.

Created under an Obama-era executive order, DACA gives some undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. as children the chance to receive a renewable two-year period of deferred action from deportation and become eligible for a work permit.

Legal experts have looked back on Roberts’ June vote that blocked a citizenship question from appearing on the 2020 census. The Trump administration claimed that Americans have the right to know who’s in the country illegally.

"So important for our Country that the very simple and basic "Are you a Citizen of the United States?" Question be allowed to be asked in the 2020 Census," Trump tweeted at the time.

Critics said the question would discourage illegal immigrants from participating. Census totals determine congressional seats and political boundaries.

Linda Greenhouse, a New York Times columnist who focuses on the Supreme Court, wrote last week that the parallels between the census case and DACA is not exact, "but they are striking."

She wrote that Roberts called the Commerce Department's claim in the case "contrived."

The department claimed that the question needed to be included so the Justice Department could better job enforcing the Voting Rights Act. Greenhouse said Roberts' opinion "made it clear that the court was addressing process, not substance."

Agencies are required to offer "genuine justifications for important decisions, reasons that can be scrutinized by courts and the interested public," he wrote, according to the Times. "Accepting contrived reasons would defeat the purpose of the enterprise."

The Los Angeles Times reported Monday that Dreamers' "best hope for victory almost surely depends on" Roberts. CNN reported that lawyers were crafting their argument to appeal to one justice: Roberts.

But the L.A. Times pointed out that Roberts wrote in the travel ban ruling that the country's chief executive oversees immigration enforcement. Roberts also handed two other immigration wins to the administration.

The court sided with President Trump in allowing him to enforce the travel ban on visitors from some majority Muslim countries and Roberts voted in favor of Trump shifting military dollars to fund the wall.

Janet Napolitano, the University of California president who served as Obama's homeland security secretary when DACA was created, said the administration seems to recognize that ending DACA protections would be unpopular.

"And so perhaps they think it better that they be ordered by the court to do it as opposed to doing it correctly on their own," Napolitano said in an interview with The Associated Press. She is a named plaintiff in the litigation.

Trump has said a ruling in his favor would force Democrats back to the table and a "bipartisan deal will be made to the benefit of all."

The Associated Press contributed to this report

Source link
Read also:
Chicago Tribune › 3 weeks ago
Chief Justice John Roberts is one of the few remaining conservative justices on the Supreme Court who has shown a willingness to side with liberals on high-profile cases
NBC News › Opinions › 3 weeks ago
Given the questions in court Tuesday, the justices appear once again to be divided along ideological lines .It will be up to Roberts to rein in the Trump administration (or not).
ABC News › 2 months ago
As a partisan battle over impeachment grips Washington, Chief Justice John Roberts, in a rare public appearance, defended the independence of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Washington Times › Politics › 1 month ago
In an impeachment trial in the Senate, President Trump would look up to see one of his Washington establishment foes, Supreme Court Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., presiding over the historic proceedings from the dais in the upper chamber.
Reuters › Politics › 2 months ago
U.S. Chief Justice John Roberts, speaking at a New York synagogue on Tuesday night, lamented the perception that the Supreme Court is becoming politicized and that the justices' decisions are guided primarily by their partisan affiliation.
Fox News › Politics › 2 months ago
U.S. Chief Justice John Roberts Tuesday said that justices on the Supreme Court are not swayed by politics despite the current fraught political climate.
USA Today › 0 month ago
DACA recipients and supporters protested at the United States Supreme Court Friday to demand the high court defend DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals). (Nov. 8)
CNN › Politics › 3 weeks ago
Lawyers trying to save an Obama-era program that defers the deportation of certain undocumented young adults are strategically directing their arguments to one man: Chief Justice John Roberts.
New York Post › 2 months ago
US Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas was out sick Monday as the nation’s highest court opened its new term after a three-month break. Before the court heard its first arguments of the day, Chief Justice John Roberts said Thomas, 71, was...
Washington Times › 2 weeks ago
Iowa Supreme Court Justice David Wiggins will serve as the court’s chief justice until a successor to Chief Justice Mark Cady can be appointed.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google