Ukraine didn't interfere in 2016, Trump officials testified

Politico Politics 1 week ago

Two top officials who served on President Donald Trump’s National Security Council staff testified that they had seen no evidence that the Ukraine government interfered in the 2016 election, contradicting a claim the president has made in public and private.

The former officials, Fiona Hill and Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman, were responding to questions from House impeachment investigators, who released transcripts of their depositions on Friday.

The testimony undercuts a conspiracy theory that has been pushed by Rudy Giuliani, the president’s personal lawyer, as he sought to upend the intelligence community’s conclusion that Russia sought to help Trump defeat Hillary Clinton in 2016.

According to Giuliani, Ukrainian officials conspired with the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee to help boost the Democratic nominee’s campaign and damage Trump’s candidacy. No evidence has emerged to support that idea.

In his testimony, Vindman said there was no “factual basis” for such claims. “I am, frankly, unaware of any authoritative basis for Ukranian interference in 2016 elections, based on my knowledge,” he said.

Hill went further, telling lawmakers she had no reason to believe that the intelligence community’s assessment was wrong or that Ukraine interfered in the 2016 election, though she clarified that she was referring only to the government in Kyiv.

Hill appeared frustrated by repeated questions from the Republicans’ lead counsel about a POLITICO article from January 2017, which said a Ukrainian-American working for the DNC had met up with top officials at the Ukrainian embassy to discuss Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort’s ties to Russia.

“It is a fiction that the Ukrainian government was launching an effort to upend our election, upend our election to mess with our Democratic systems,” Hill testified.

Asked whether a Ukrainian-American might have been interested in “injecting” negative information about Manafort into the press, Hill retorted that the same could be said of the Ukrainian-American operatives Lev Parnas and Igor Fruman, two Giuliani associates “who were also trying to subvert our democracy and who managed to get one of our ambassadors sacked.”

Parnas and Fruman had been lobbying members of Congress and the administration to pressure the State Department into firing U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch, whose anti-corruption efforts were interfering with Parnas and Fruman’s business interests.

“If you're also trying to peddle an alternative variation of whether the Ukrainians subverted our election, I don't want to be part of that, and I will not be part of it,” Hill said. “What

we're dealing with now is a situation where we are at risk of saying that everything that happened in 2016 was a result of Ukraine in some fashion.”

“I'm extremely concerned that this is a rabbit hole that we're all going to go down in between now and the 2020 election, and it will be to all of our detriment,” she added. “And I just want to, if I've done anything, leave a message to you that we should all be greatly concerned about what the Russians intend to do in 2020. And any information that they can provide, you know, that basically deflects our attention away from what they did and what they're planning on doing is very useful to them.”

It wasn’t just Giuliani who has advanced the Ukraine-did-it conspiracy theory. During his July 25 call with Zelensky, Trump mentioned a somewhat garbled version of events while asking his Ukrainian counterpart to also investigate former vice president Joe Biden and his son Hunter.

“I would like you to find out what happened with this whole situation with Ukraine,” Trump told Zelensky, going on to make a convoluted reference to a DNC server that he apparently, and falsely, believes is in Ukraine.

During the 2016 campaign, hackers linked to Russia broke into the DNC’s computer system and released internal emails of discussions between top committee officials.

The publication of the emails, which suggested to some that DNC leaders were conspiring to help Clinton win the Democratic primary over Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, led to the resignation of chairwoman Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, cast a pall over the nominating convention and embittered many voters on the left against the party establishment.

The idea that Ukraine was behind the DNC hack may first have been planted in Trump’s mind by Manafort, who pushed the widely debunked theory shortly before the November election, according to FBI documents released last week and first published by BuzzFeed.

The allegation was made by Rick Gates, Manafort’s former deputy, who broke with his boss to testify as part of the Russia probe led by special counsel Robert Mueller.

“Gates recalled Manafort saying the hack was likely carried out by the Ukrainians, not the Russians, which parroted a narrative Kilimnik often supported,” FBI notes say, referring to Konstantin Kilimnik, a Manafort business partner who has been linked to Russian intelligence.

“Kilimnik also opined the hack could have been perpetrated by Russian operatives in Ukraine,” the FBI memo said.

Hill testified to House lawmakers that she had met Kilimnik years earlier, and believed he was a Russian operative—and that Ukraine under its previous president Petro Poroshenko had allowed Kilimnik, who was a witness in the Mueller investigation, to flee to Russia.

“All of my staff thought he was a Russian spy,” she said.


Source link
Read also:
The Hill › 1 month ago
President Trump accused Democrats of "interfering" with the 2020 election and the 2016 election as he faces an impeachment probe based on an allegation that he solicited foreign help to interfere in the 2020 contest....
Axios › Politics › 1 month ago
For the 3rd time in 4 years, President Trump has asked another country to interfere in U.S. elections.The big picture: In July 2016, Trump said Russia should "find" and release Hillary Clinton's emails. In July 2019, he told Ukraine to investigate the...
Express › Politics › 2 weeks ago
LABOUR'S new candidate for Ashfield argued Brexiteers "didn't know what they were voting for" despite 70 percent of Ashfield voting for Leave in the 2016 referendum.
The Independent › Politics › 1 day ago
Military veteran and vice president’s adviser both listened to president’s Ukraine conversation
Cleveland › 0 month ago
We know how Russia interfered to ensure that President Donald Trump would be elected, but how did Democrats interfere? By having the gall to vote Democrat? asks Patricia Shumaker of Fairview Park in a letter to the editor.
The Independent › Politics › 2 weeks ago
Nine of the Trump administration's nominees have been deemed 'unqualified'
The Sun › 1 month ago
VLADIMIR Putin last night joked he was “definitely” going to interfere with the 2020 US Presidential election – adding: “Just don’t tell anyone.” The Russian premier – who the FBI said mounted a huge effort to meddle in the 2016 vote...
The Independent › Politics › 0 month ago
'We still have no legally binding guarantee that UK rights will keep pace with EU minimum standards'
The Hill › Politics › 1 month ago
An IRS official filed a complaint alleging that he was told that at least one Treasury Department official tried to interfere with an audit of President Trump or Vice President Mike Pence's tax returns, according to the W...
New York Post › Politics › 0 month ago
The acting US ambassador to Ukraine testified that he was told that the release of US military aid to the country was dependent on Ukraine publicly vowing to investigate Joe Biden and his son as well as the 2016 election, a new report said Tuesday...
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR