Trump attorney vows to go to Supreme Court in tax return case after appeals court allows subpoena

Fox News Politics 1 month ago
Federal appeals court rules Trump's tax returns must be turned over to a state grand jury; chief White House correspondent John Roberts reports from the North Lawn.

The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals has denied President Trump’s challenge of a lower court’s ruling that allowed New York City prosecutors to subpoena records including Trump's tax returns, with the president's attorney saying he will take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Trump was attempting to block the grand jury subpoena, which was issued to accounting firm Mazars USA by the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office in a 34-page ruling handed down Monday morning.

“The decision of the 2nd Circuit will be taken to the Supreme Court,” Trump’s attorney Jay Sekulow said in a statement. “The issue raised in this case goes to the heart of our Republic. The constitutional issues are significant.”

Trump has argued that the subpoena is unenforceable because a sitting president should not be subject to a state criminal process. The 2nd Circuit disagreed.

“We hold, however, that any presidential immunity from state criminal process does not extend to investigative steps like the grand jury subpoena at issue here,” the ruling written by Chief Judge Robert Katzmann said.

Fox News senior judicial analyst Judge Andrew Napolitano on Trump's legal team filing emergency appeal.

The subpoena, issued Aug. 29, 2019, requested a variety of documents pertaining to Trump and his businesses, including “[t]ax returns and related schedules, in draft, as‐filed, and amended form” that Mazars possesses. Trump challenged it, arguing that he is not subject to the state criminal process while in office, and asked a federal District Court to declare the subpoena unenforceable during Trump’s presidency.

In an October ruling, U.S. District Court Judge Victor Marrero abstained, claiming the issue was not a matter for federal courts, but also provided an alternative holding stating that Trump’s immunity argument was unfounded and overbroad.

Marrero, who was appointed by then-President Bill Clinton, wrote that “the expansive notion of constitutional immunity invoked here to shield the president from judicial process would constitute an overreach of executive power,” and that Trump’s argument essentially claims “that a constitutional domain exists in this country in which not only the president, but, derivatively, relatives and persons and business entities associated with him in potentially unlawful private activities, are in fact above the law.”

The 2nd Circuit briefly put the subpoena on hold once Trump appealed the lower court’s decision, but now they are allowing it to be enforced.

With Sekulow vowing to bring the case to the Supreme Court, Trump’s next move could be a request for a temporary injunction blocking the subpoena at least while the high court determines whether to take up the case.

Fox News’ John Roberts contributed to this report.

Source link
Read also:
Sputnik International › 1 month ago
WASHINGTON (Sputnik) - US President Donald Trump will request the Supreme Court review an earlier appeals court ruling requiring him to turn over tax return records to the Manhattan District Attorney, Trump attorney Jay Sekulow said in a statement on...
The Hill › Politics › 1 month ago
President Trump on Friday urged a federal appeals court to reverse a lower court's decision dismissing his lawsuit over New York prosecutors' subpoena for his tax returns.In his opening brief in his appeal, Trump r...
The Hill › Politics › 1 month ago
The Manhattan district attorney's office on Tuesday urged a federal appeals court to deny President Trump's effort to block prosecutors' subpoena for his tax returns.Trump has "established neither a likelihood of s...
The Hill › 2 weeks ago
The Manhattan district attorney's office asked the Supreme Court to reject President Trump's effort to shield his tax returns from a grand jury subpoena, in a case where the president's lawyers have argued that he is immu...
Raw Story › 1 month ago
A federal appeals court announced on Monday that it will not stop a New York grand jury from obtaining President Donald Trump’s financial information. Last month, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted Trump’s attorneys a temporary stay...
The Hill › Politics › 1 month ago
Deutsche Bank doesn't have any tax returns belonging to President Trump that pertain to a subpoena from House Democrats, federal appeals court judges in New York said Thursday.The appeals court denied a motion from...
New York Post › 1 month ago
Lawyers for President Trump are asking an appeals court to indefinitely bar the Manhattan D.A. from getting his tax returns and other financial documents in the event the case goes all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. “The President respectfully...
The Hill › 0 month ago
President Trump's personal attorneys told a federal judge on Friday that they intend to petition the Supreme Court next week to review an appeals court decision that said the Manhattan district attorney can subpoena the p...
CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
President Donald Trump has asked the DC Circuit Court of Appeals to rehear his attempt to stop a subpoena of his longtime accounting firm, this time with Trump asking the full appellate court to reconsider his case.
New York Daily News › Politics › 1 month ago
The 34-page ruling by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals is another defeat for Trump in the legal battle over his tax returns. Vance’s request for the records is on hold as the case makes it way to the Supreme Court.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google