The nightmare of counting MPs before big votes in the Commons

The Independent Politics 1 month ago

“Keep doing the numbers; they’re very useful,” a Labour MP said to me as we passed in the gothic cloister off New Palace Yard. I was torn between pride and alarm – alarm because it seemed MPs might now be using my Twitter account as a reliable source of information about how their fellow members are intending to vote. 

Predicting close votes in the House of Commons is a nightmare. I understand people who find it frustrating that journalists are obsessed with who will win, rather than with the substance of who ought to win and why. But winning votes is the bottom line of politics. You can be as right as you like, but unless you win the votes, it doesn’t matter. 

So that is why I post updates on Twitter trying to add up the numbers before big votes. But the scope for getting things wrong is great, because any vote in the Commons is complicated, with 650 movable parts.

I start any calculation by deducting MPs who do not take part in votes: the seven Sinn Fein MPs, who do not take their seats (although they do use the facilities of the Palace of Westminster), and the speaker and his three deputies (one Conservative and two Labour, so that they cancel out, given that John Bercow was originally elected as a Conservative). 

Then in most votes, you have to deduct two tellers on each side. These are the MPs who count the votes and announce the result in the chamber: they don’t vote themselves but they obviously support their side. So that means you include them if you are talking about how many MPs support something, such as the Brexit deal, but you exclude them when calculating the numbers that will be read out in house. 

Anti-Brexit protesters fill Parliament Square in London, after Prime Minister Boris Johnson delivered a statement in the House of Commons on his new Brexit deal
Protesters on Whitehall in London during an Extinction Rebellion climate change protest
European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker and Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson shake hands during a news conference after agreeing on a Brexit deal, in Brussels
A man walks his dog through the fallen leaves in Clarkes Gardens, Allerton in Liverpool
Police officers carry away an activist as Extinction Rebellion protesters block a road with a caravan in central London
Queen Elizabeth II sits with Prince Charles on the Sovereign's throne ahead of delivering the Queen's Speech at the State Opening of Parliament
Great Britain's Joe Fraser competes on Parallel Bars during the World Gymnastics Championships in Stuttgart, Germany. He claimed GB's second gold with his victory. The 20-year-old from Birmingham nailed his routine to score 15.0 then watched as a series of rivals failed to live up to his total
St Helens players celebrate with the trophy after they won the Super League Grand Final at Old Trafford in Manchester. They beat Salford Red Devils 23-6
Richard Ratcliffe, husband of British-Iranian aid worker Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe jailed in Tehran since 2016, holds his daughter Gabriella during a news conference in London. Their five-year-old daughter has arrived back in Britain, after making the "bittersweet" decision to bring her home
Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar and British Prime Minister Boris Johnson at Thornton Manor. Their meeting focused on further Brexit proposals
Wales survived an almighty scare against Fiji to secure quarter-final spot at the rugby world cup. Warren Gatland’s side recovered from a 10-0 deficit thanks to a hat-trick from Josh Adams
Protesters dubbed the Red Rebels at Millbank at the junction with Great College Street, during an Extinction Rebellion protest in Westminster
Final preparations are made in front of a reproduction of Michelangelo's 'The Last Judgement', ahead of the opening of for the 'Michelangelo: A Different View' exhibition at Hull Minister
A car drives through a flooded street in Whitley Bay in Northumberland
Thousands took to the streets of Edinburgh today to march in support of a second Scottish independence referendum
A 12ft sculpture of a gorilla, entitled 'Gorilla Apocalypse', created by Luke Kite entirely from scrap car bumpers and panels discarded in the last decade is on display at the British Ironwork Centre in Oswestry, Shropshire
Police stands in front of the Treasury building during an Extinction Rebellion protest in London
Ex-Thomas Cook employees demonstrate in London after delivering a petition calling for a full inquiry into Thomas Cook's collapse and for the company's directors to pay back their bonuses
A road in Alum Rock, Birmingham is flooded after persistent heavy rain
Two tourists pose for pictures in front of Union and EU flags outside the Houses of Parliament in London
A sheep on London Bridge as Freemen of the City of London took up their historic entitlement to drive sheep over the bridge, which was once London's only river crossing
An Aldabra giant tortoise is fed watermelon as a treat at the Malvern Autumn Show, at the Three Counties Showground near Malvern in Worcestershire
Gallery assistants pose with an artwork entitled 'Devolved Parliament' by British artist Banksy, during a press view in London ahead of Sotheby's contemporary art sale, as part of the Frieze Art Fair
England's Jonathan Joseph is tackled by United State's Marcel Brache during their group match at the Rugby World Cup in Japan. England scored seven tries on their way to winning 45-7
Tributes for former Rangers player Fernando Ricksen at Ibrox Stadium. Today, the funeral procession will pass Ibrox Stadium before making the journey to Wellington Church
A person dressed as a caricature of Prime Minister Boris Johnson in a prison uniform stands outside the Supreme Court after it ruled that his decision to suspend Parliament was illegal
Thomas Cook aircraft are parked up at Manchester Airport on the day they collapsed after rescue talks failed. A total of 22,000 jobs - including 9,000 in UK - are to be lost following administration. More than 150,000 British holidaymakers need to be brought home, with the government and CAA hiring dozens of charter planes to fly customers home free of charge
Fire performer Penella Bee performs before people take part in the North East Skinny Dip at Druridge Bay in Nothumberland, an annual event that marks the Autumn Equinox and raises money for MIND - the Mental Health Charity
Protesters gather for a march and rally organised by "The People's Vote" in Brighton, to call for politicians to give the public a final say referendum on Brexit
Protesters in London joined millions across world to demand urgent action to save planet in the largest environmental protest in history
Rapper Dave poses with the Mercury Prize: Albums of the Year Award at Apollo
A surfer in action during sunrise at Tynemouth on the north east coast
Protesters dressed as the Incredible Hulk and Robocop outside the Supreme Court in London where judges are due to consider legal challenges to Prime Minister Boris Johnson's decision to suspend Parliament. The Supreme Court will hear appeals over three days from two separate challenges to the prorogation of Parliament brought in England and Scotland
Farmer Tom Hoggard harvests pumpkins at Howe Bridge Farm in Yorkshire, ahead of Halloween
Team Europe celebrate winning the Solheim Cup at Gleneagles in Auchterarder, Scotland. Europe won the last three singles matches to claim victory 14½-13½
Sunset at St Mary's Lighthouse in Whitley Bay
Activists from PETA stage a demonstration outside a venue during London Fashion Week in London, Britain
Australia's Marnus Labuschagne attempts to stop a boundary in the fifth Test
Storm clouds gather over the pier just off the North East coast at South Shields
The peloton rides past the Angel of the North during stage four of the Tour of Britain from Gateshead to Kendal
A penny farthing cyclist rides past St. John's, Smith Square, Westminster, London
Australia celebrate the wicket of England's Craig Overton, which meant they won the fourth test and retained the Ashes
Manchester City celebrate after Caroline Weir scored during their Women's Super League match against Manchester United at Etihad Stadium. The WSL attendance record was smashed with 31,213 people watching the first Manchester derby of Women’s Super League era – nearly six times the previous WSL record
A bull bumps into a plain clothes police officer (left) while being walked by Prime Minister Boris Johnson during his visit to Darnford Farm in Banchory near Aberdeen. It coincided with the publication of Lord Bew's review and an announcement of extra funding for Scottish farmers
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon cuts the hair of David Torrance MSP raising £1000 for the charity Maggie's Centre in Kirkcaldy at the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh
Australia's David Warner looks dejected after being dismissed by England's Stuart Broad during day one of the fourth Ashes Test at Old Trafford in Manchester
Anti Brexit demonstrators attend a protest at Parliament Square. Lawmakers returned from their summer recess Tuesday for a pivotal day in British politics as they challenged Prime Minister Boris Johnson's insistence that the UK leave the European Union on 31 October, even without a withdrawal agreement to cushion the economic blow
Set building begins on Waterloo Place in Edinburgh ahead of filming for Fast and Furious 9
Members of the Royal Southern Yacht Club and the Island Sailing Club take part during the annual cricket match between the clubs, which takes place on the Bramble Bank sandbank in the middle of the Solent at low tide
Anti-Brexit protesters demonstrate at Whitehall in London

The next trap is non-voters. MPs tend not to abstain in big Brexit votes. The last time Theresa May asked for a vote on her deal there were only four non-voters, and you can never be sure if they are deliberate abstentions or something else. In an earlier vote, Douglas Ross, the Scottish Tory MP, didn’t vote because his wife was giving birth. 

But non-voters move the winning line for any vote. On a full turnout, at the moment the number needed for a majority is 320, or 318 excluding the tellers. But if one MP doesn’t vote, a 317-317 tie is possible. Then you have to know what the conventions are for the speaker using his casting vote (usually for the status quo or to keep options open). 

Much excitement today, therefore, when Jared O’Mara, the former Labour MP for Sheffield Hallam – who hardly ever votes – was spotted getting on a train to London.

Then another pitfall is what happened on Friday, which is that, no sooner had I tallied the numbers on Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal and concluded there were only one or two votes in it, along came an amendment to the motion to postpone the big vote and mean I’d have to recalculate everything. So that is what I shall do.

Yours,

John Rentoul​

Chief political commentator


Source link
Read also:
The Sun › Politics › 2 months ago
BORIS Johnson could give MPs an early vote on his Brexit deal BEFORE the crucial EU summit to show Brussels his plans have Commons support. Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay said the PM was “considering” a poll after he was asked to do so by MPs...
Express › 1 month ago
JOHN BERCOW was left powerless as Conservative MPs stormed out of the House of Commons as MPs voted to delay the Brexit vote under the Letwin Amendment.
The Sun › Politics › 2 months ago
JEREMY Corbyn will tell Labour MPs not to back Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal if it goes to a Commons vote. Mr Corbyn said he would “caution” against voting for the agreement – but refused to say if he would remove the whip from rebelling MPs...
BBC News › 1 week ago
Mary and Esther have been counting election votes together in Warrington Town Hall since the 1960s.
Reuters › 1 month ago
Mauritius electoral authorities began counting votes on Friday after a parliamentary election dominated by calls for a fairer distribution of wealth on the prosperous Indian Ocean island.
Express › 1 month ago
A FURIOUS Brexit voter ripped into MPs in the House of Commons who “begged” Brits for their votes in the 2017 general election and have not delivered on the historic 2016 EU referendum.
The Guardian › Politics › 1 month ago
MPs backed the motion by 299 votes to 70 – leaving Boris Johnson 135 votes short of the votes he needed for the division to have force
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 1 month ago
A company is hosting "Nightmare Before Christmas"-themed festivals and booze cruises across the United States. The first Nightmare Before Brews Cruise departs from Portland, Oregon, on November 23. Events are happening in a number of US cities...
The Sun › Politics › 1 month ago
BRITAIN could be heading for a second General Election in two years if two-thirds of MPs vote back Boris Johnson’s demands. But what time will MPs be voting? Here’s the latest. When will MPs vote on Bojo’s call for another election? MPs are due...
Mirror Online › Politics › 1 month ago
Sir Lindsay will chair debates in the House of Commons. But before he even starts trying to tame MPs, he's got his hands full with a full on menagerie of pets with unusual names
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR