Out with Turkey, in with Australia: How to fix 'brain dead' NATO

London: Is Nato suffering the 70-year itch? Repeated declarations of solidarity from the alliance's leaders this week hardly masked the squabbling between Presidents Trump, Macron and Erdogan or the carping stage whispers from Justin Trudeau. Nor did the summit do much to contradict Mr Macron's assertion that Nato's lack of clear common strategies for the future indicated its "brain death".

Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg made a brave effort to talk up Nato's new force structures and members' commitments to an alphabet soup of reforms. But bureaucratic tinkering cannot mask the risk of the alliance falling into a "permanent vegetative state" unless it grasps the need for bigger thinking. What is the point of Nato decades after the collapse of the USSR? Everyone seems to have a different answer. Does the solidarity still exist for its members to come to each other's aid? It's doubtful.

French President Emmanuel Macron said a lack of leadership was contributing to the 'brain death' of the alliance.

Let's not downplay matters. The French President's call "to reassess the reality of what Nato is" is evidence of an alliance in crisis. Mr Macron diagnosed Mr Trump's lukewarm enthusiasm for Nato as the sickness, and prescribed the creation of some sort of EU army as the medicine. For Mr Trump, the big problem is that European allies have relied on US troops while complacently offering little themselves. He has been happy to take credit for an increase in Nato contributions, but his continued support for the alliance can hardly be taken for granted.

Then there is the problem of Turkey, a Nato member but nevertheless accused by Mr Macron during the summit of having colluded with Islamic State jihadists in Syria. Under President Erdogan, Turkey today has turned against the Western values that Nato ultimately defends.

All told, this is an alliance that is fraying at the edges - unable to pull in the same direction and unwilling to get to grips with why.

Overhanging all this is a global threat environment that suggests now is hardly the time to take a lax attitude to defence. There is no question that the democratic world faces unprecedented threats.

Donald Trump has been asking all NATO nations to spend 2 per cent of GDP on defence.

The rise of China and its rapidly growing co-ordination with Russia is dramatic. In effect, the two are creating a giant Eurasian power bloc. Even when Stalin and Mao were allies, Moscow and Beijing lacked the economic and technological resources now available to Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. Russian missile technology plus Chinese money makes for a superpower comparable to the US.

While it's understandable for a defensive alliance to prioritise warding off immediate threats, the failure this week to move beyond relatively ephemeral discussions on issues such as space warfare to grapple with broader fundamentals suggests that Mr Macron's plea for a wider discussion about Nato's underlying issues has fallen on deaf ears.

Above all is the question of whether a regional alliance even makes sense in a globalising world. There is a strong argument that leaders would be better off supporting a worldwide alliance built on shared values, rather than geographical proximity.

For what it's worth, my view is that if Nato were reoriented around the defence of values as well as territory it would secure a greater element of unity. Current members have far more in common with the likes of Australia, New Zealand and Israel than they do with Turkey. Expelling members who flout democratic principles while welcoming those who hold these values dear would give the alliance the chance to punish Mr Erdogan. Meanwhile, using the promise of future membership as leverage would encourage more of the world's despots to adopt democratic and human rights reforms.

Former foreign minister Alexander Downer also suggested the alliance should expand to include like-minded democracies.

Inviting new members from other areas of the globe - in particular from the Pacific region - would also help assuage some of Mr Trump's concerns about the rise of China. Such a reorganisation would not be straightforward, but it would create an alliance that had some sense of purpose and togetherness - the malaise currently at the heart of modern Nato. At the very least, this is the sort of discussion that an alliance desperate to prove it is not "brain dead" ought to have been having.

The Telegraph, London

Source link
Read also:
Business Insider › Politics › 1 week ago
NATO leaders are meeting in the UK on Tuesday and Wednesday. The summit kicked off just as awkwardly as expected, with President Donald Trump attacking French Emmanuel Macron for saying last month that NATO was going brain-dead. In a Tuesday morning...
RT › 1 month ago
NATO is alive and well and integral to Europe’s security, German chancellor Angela Merkel and NATO Secretary Jens Stoltenberg have insisted, hitting back at French President Emmanuel Macron’s claim the alliance is “brain-dead.” Read Full...
RT › 1 month ago
French President Emmanuel Macron was the perfect man to diagnose NATO as being ‘brain-dead’, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov quipped, saying Moscow is ready for the bloc’s recovery from all ailments. Read Full Article at RT.com
New York Post › 1 week ago
President Trump, a longtime critic of NATO, went to bat for the trans-Atlantic alliance on Tuesday over “nasty” comments from French President Emmanuel Macron that NATO is “brain dead” because of lackluster US leadership. “It’s a tough...
Breitbart › Politics › 1 week ago
Hungary's Péter Szijjártó has praised the American leadership in NATO and said that he did not agree that NATO was brain dead.
Reuters › 2 weeks ago
Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan said on Friday that Emmanuel Macron's comments on NATO reflect a "sick and shallow" understanding, telling the French president "you should check whether you are brain dead".
The New York Times › 2 weeks ago
Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan said on Friday that Emmanuel Macron's comments on NATO reflect a "sick and shallow" understanding, telling the French president "you should check whether you are brain dead".
The Sun › Sports › 0 month ago
MMA FIGHTER Vince Murdock has undergone intensive brain surgery to fix his rare brain condition. The 28-year old went into hospital this week to fix his Moyamoya condition. View this post on Instagram This some how felt appropriate for a...
Express › 1 week ago
DONALD TRUMP has said NATO are making great progress “except with that country”, although he has not specified which country, after saying that President Macron's statement about NATO being "brain-dead" was a "a very nasty statement".
Metro › Lifestyle › 1 day ago
Brain zaps, brain shocks, brain shivers, or brain flips are something many people on SSRIs experience, but little is known about them.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google