Ardern was supposed to be the anti-Trump, but she failed to speak truth to power | Bryce Edwards

The Guardian Opinions 1 month ago

A meeting with US President Donald Trump was always a fraught proposition for New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern. It was never going to deliver any clear wins, and was unlikely to do her progressive reputation any favours. And that’s the outcome – Ardern’s reputation has probably taken a hit, at least amongst her own progressive constituency.

Ardern’s liberal supporters see her as the polar opposite of the US President, and she has even been labelled the “anti-Trump”. They expected her in some way to speak truth to power when meeting the man who has become synonymous with the most reactionary problems in politics today. More than anything, Ardern might have been expected to use the opportunity to push Trump hard on the issue of climate change.

Instead, Ardern came out of the meeting typically upbeat, exuding her trademark diplomacy. She described the meeting as a “perfectly productive, warm, solid bi- lateral”, trotting out the usual platitudes about US-NZ relations, and highlighting Trump’s purported interest in New Zealand.

There were some tidbits: we were informed of Trump’s somewhat incongruous interest in the gun buyback scheme established by Ardern’s government immediately following the Christchurch mosque terror attacks. But, as signalled prior to her departure for the US, trade was top of Ardern’s agenda, with climate change seemingly barely touched upon.

Unfortunately for Ardern, the New Zealand media is now giving plenty of coverage of her positivity towards Trump, mixed with reports of dissatisfaction over her failure to push climate change action at the meeting. And to make matters worse for her, Trump has now tweeted that the good news stories about their conversation are “true” and that it was “A wonderful meeting!”

In one sense the meeting was a success. Many conservatives will be very happy with a positive diplomatic outcome, and Ardern’s focus on trade. Prior to the meeting conservative pundits congratulated Ardern for even securing the meeting with Trump and lobbied for her to use it to push a free trade agenda, which has long been New Zealand’s diplomatic focus with the US.

Ardern’s meeting ticked the usual objectives for a New Zealand prime minister meeting the US President. Business as usual has been achieved. Therein lies the problem for Ardern.

Ardern isn’t supposed to be a traditional PM. She came to power riding a wave of enthusiasm for being different. Jacindamania was based on the expectation that she would do politics differently and would reject business as usual. She promised “transformational change”.

Now this anti-Trump politician has had her first formal meeting with the real Trump, and nothing much has changed. While no one can have reasonably expected that her meeting with Trump would produce immediate results, there was certainly an expectation that she would at least emphasise the need for action on climate change.

Ardern has previously campaigned on making climate change her “generation’s nuclear-free moment”. In inviting this comparison, she was consciously evoking a time when New Zealand stood up to the US Government, banning American nuclear ships from visiting our ports in the face of enormous diplomatic and trade pressure. While contentious at the time, this defiant stance is now a source of immense national pride for New Zealanders.

Climate change is also why Ardern travelled to New York this week. And her meeting with Trump was preceded by her speech at the UN in which she determinedly remained on message and suggested trade was an answer to climate change.

To her misfortune, Ardern had to follow Greta Thunberg, who excoriated world leaders for their failure to act on climate change, describing this as a betrayal.

Thunberg’s address made it clear that there is now a new anti-Trump on the world stage – one who it is impossible to imagine meeting with Trump and letting him get away with business as usual, or proposing trade deals as a solution for climate change.

Ardern is also fighting a rising tide of cynicism at home over whether her actions match her rhetoric. The New Zealand Labour Party and, crucially, Ardern’s own office, is currently embroiled in a major sexual assault scandal. This is on the heels of failures to deliver promised changes – most notably the flagship housing policy has turned into a train wreck that her government is trying to salvage, without much success.

Ardern’s performance in New York is not going to be enough to assuage the uneasy feeling that for all Ardern’s claims to be different, it’s very much business as usual.

She described climate change in her speech this morning as an “extraordinary threat” but, right now, her response to that threat is looking – as we say “pretty ordinary.”

Dr Bryce Edwards is a political scientist and commentator at Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.


Source link
Read also:
The Guardian › Opinions › 2 months ago
New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern’s credentials at home and abroad as a new kind of leader all hang on her next moveIt’s just shy of a year ago that Jacinda Ardern stood in the UN general assembly and spoke in support of the #MeToo movement...
The Guardian › 2 months ago
New Zealand PM blames jet lag after hailing ‘relationship with China – excuse me sorry, with Japan’New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern has blamed jetlag for an embarrassing gaffe on her first official visit to Japan.Ardern had only just...
The Sun › Lifestyle › 1 month ago
SIMON Cowell is getting ready to unleash X Factor: Celebrity and with it comes Cole and Edwards. But just who are the singing duo? Here’s the lowdown. Who are Cole and Edwards? Brendan Cole found fame on Strictly Come Dancing, while Jeremy Edwards...
The Sun › Entertainment › 0 month ago
FURIOUS 13 Reasons Why fans claim Netflix made a MASSIVE blunder and ‘forgot’ Bryce was shot in final episode. The teen drama’s third season focused on a whodunnit after school bully and rapist Bryce was found dead. In an early episode from the...
New York Post › Sports › 1 month ago
Bryce Harper is getting his wish. Before booking a spot in the World Series with a 7-4 win over the Cardinals Tuesday night, the Nationals tweeted, “We want to bring a title back to D.C.,” teasing the mistaken words of their former star Bryce...
The Inquisitr › 1 month ago
Although Ryan Edwards and his wife Mackenzie Edwards appear on Teen Mom OG, they remain relatively quiet on social media. As previously reported by The Inquisitr, Mackenzie announced her second pregnancy with Ryan back in July and, since then, she...
The Guardian › 1 month ago
Prime minister says she and Trump discussed her country’s reforms on sidelines of UN general assemblyJacinda Ardern, the New Zealand prime minister, has said Donald Trump expressed “interest” in her country’s gun buyback program, as the...
The Sun › Lifestyle › 2 weeks ago
HUW Edwards is one of the most well-known news presenters in the UK. In October 2019 he hit the headlines himself after chasing a burglar off in his PJs – here’s what we know about heroic Huw. Who is Huw Edwards? Huw Edwards, 58, is a journalist...
The Guardian › 2 months ago
New Zealand prime minister says relationship with US counterpart is strong despite previous run-insNew Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern will hold her first ever formal meeting with Donald Trump next week; the first time the two leaders have sat...
CNN › 2 months ago
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has just kicked off her first official trip to Japan as leader. Unfortunately for her, she appeared to confuse it for China on arrival.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR