WeWork’s entire board should be fired before Adam Neumann

Business Insider Opinions 2 months ago

The WeWork IPO train wreck is being blamed on Adam Neumann.

Neumann is the "visionary" founder and CEO who apparently has a taste for expensive tequila and blowing millions of venture capital dollars on company ragers and on himself, all while giddily running a company devoid of profits or even basic business fundamentals.

Now some members of Neumann's board of directors want to fire him because it might be the only way to save the company's IPO. Billions are at stake.

According to The New York Times' Michael de la Merced, Andrew Ross Sorkin and David Gelles, the motivating factor behind the conspiracy to dethrone Neumann is that major money managers refuse to invest in a WeWork IPO unless a different, more experienced operator is brought in.

If he doesn't go willingly, getting rid of Neumann won't be easy. He has been allowed to accumulate a lot of power. Even though his 20X voting shares have been knocked down to 10X following public backlash, Neumann still has enough control to fire his entire board if he wants to.

Perhaps more significantly, WeWork's board needs to take a hard look in the mirror. Each member has failed miserably at their job. And that's because startup boardrooms are broken.

A public company's board of directors is supposed to look out for shareholder interest.

But the job of a startup's board is less clear-cut and more problematic. These boards are often clubby groups of VC insiders. Their unspoken primary objective is to look out for their own self-interest and to protect their returns.

From the earliest stages of a startup, investors back founders, not companies.

That's because ideas alone are worthless. It takes a founder with grit, vision and the ability to execute to transform a good idea into a billion-dollar business.

VCs know that without someone like Adam Neumann at the helm, someone who is said to be one heck of a salesman, WeWork's valuation would be worth nowhere near $47 billion.

The visionary founder is considered so integral to the ultimate success of a startup that the board lets them get away with a lot. Business metrics get ignored, while the founder's power grows. Investors are not incentivized to push back while a startup is on the rise. If they do, they're viewed as being anti-founder — a bad reputation to have in the startup world. And after all, this is their cash cow. With no Neumann, there's no $47 billion pot of gold.

So there go all the checks and balances. Neumann, for all his excesses, is just the culmination of a trend that's been going on for years. The all-powerful startup founder has free reign to do almost anything they want, short of murder.

Until a startup gets so big that the public starts paying attention.

Keep in mind that by the time today's startups IPO, they have grown into giant entities — like WeWork, Uber or Airbnb — whose business practices and operations affect entire industries. At that point the public, whether it be Wall Street investors or other stakeholders, starts doing the board of directors' job for them — questioning the sustainability of the business, and the practices of the CEO.

And suddenly, the board is in a tight spot. Now billions are on the line if they don't turn against the founder who made the company what it is.

There's only been one recent example of a board successfully overthrowing a powerful visionary founder: Uber's Travis Kalanick. That ouster was driven largely by Bill Gurley, a partner at venture capital firm Benchmark who felt billions were on the line for himself and his LPs if he didn't make a drastic leadership change at Uber.

Benchmark is also on the board of WeWork.

Kalanick's ouster took six months and a ferocious mental chess game before Kalanick willingly gave up his CEO role. It was ugly.

With Neumann, the WeWork board is already apparently contemplating digging into things like alleged drug use and mismanagement of company funds to force his hand, if he doesn't step aside.

Maybe Neumann should fire his entire board.

It's either them or him, and it's debatable which is worse.

Source link
Read also:
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
WeWork's board is considering replacing founder Adam Neumann as CEO amid the company's disastrous attempt to go public. There's just one problem: WeWork's board of directors doesn't have the authority to do that. Neumann controls the voting power of...
Business Insider › Finance › 3 weeks ago
Former WeWork CEO Adam Neumann retains the right to name directors to its board, even after being ousted from the troubled coworking company, Fast Company reported Monday. As part of his exit agreement with WeWork, Neumann can name a director and a...
Business Insider › Finance › 1 month ago
Ex-WeWork CEO Adam Neumann inspired Halloween costumes this year. WeWork has been in the news for its failed IPO attempt and ousting founder Adam Neumann. The company has since been bailed out by SoftBank, and Neumann reportedly received $1.7 billion...
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 3 months ago
Rebekah Paltrow Neumann cofounded WeWork in 2010 alongside her husband, Adam Neumann, and Miguel McKelvey. Investor pushback has led WeWork to strip back her influence over the company, including removing her from succession planning in the event of...
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
Some board members at coworking startup WeWork aim to push out CEO Adam Neumann, according to a report from the Wall Street Journal. The board could meet this week and might discuss Neumann becoming WeWork's nonexecutive chairman, the Journal reported...
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
WeWork co-founder Adan Neumann stepped down as CEO of the home-sharing startup on Tuesday. Neumann will remain at WeWork as non-executive chairman of the board. Two WeWork executives, Arthur Minson and Sebastian Gunningham, will take over as co-CEO in...
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
Adam and Rebekah Neumann, the founding couple behind WeWork, left the coworking company after its disastrous IPO. In March, Forbes estimated that Adam Neumann was worth $4.1 billion. Since then, Forbes has downgraded the ousted WeWork CEO, estimating...
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
WeWork co-founder and CEO Adam Neumann is stepping down as CEO, according to media reports. The company's biggest backer, several other investors, and some board members were reportedly plotting to remove Neumann as CEO after the flexible office...
Business Insider › Finance › 2 months ago
WeWork CEO Adam Neumann has stepped down, although he will stay on as non-executive chairman of the board. Neumann has a net worth of $2.2 billion, down from $4.1 billion in July, according to Forbes. WeWork's parent company, The We Company, filed its...
Business Insider › Finance › 1 month ago
Current and former WeWork employees said they were upset with the payouts that former CEO Adam Neumann will received in SoftBank's rescue deal. Neumann will resign from WeWork's board but still earn a consulting fee. One New York employee said "people...
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google