Elizabeth Warren fails kids of color

New York Daily News Opinions 3 weeks ago

Sen. Elizabeth Warren recently released her education plan. It continues the one-upmanship that has colored a primary where candidates are desperate for the backing of the nation’s teacher unions. Given that America ranks 25th among Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development countries in the 2015 PISA study, education is an issue that needs real leadership and sober solutions. But it is difficult to take the senator’s plan seriously (even the parts that are worthwhile) because it is ultimately unserious; it’s a laundry list of tree ornaments, their glitter only surpassed by the sanctimony of the rhetoric and vengeful nature of the policy agenda.

Nowhere is this more apparent than in Warren’s take on the nation’s charter schools, which serve over 3 million students who are overwhelmingly kids of color, largely located in urban areas, and for whom the nation’s traditional public schools offered sustained underperformance aplenty.

The senator wants to vest all control of the creation, oversight and closure of charter schools (commonly known as authorizing) with traditional public school districts. She would make these districts — whose achievement gaps and inflexible bureaucracies were the reason for charters in the first place — their regulators. (It’s worth noting the majority of charter authorizers in America, 89% of them, are already school districts.)

Warren’s plan talks a good deal about school finance, its unevenness, and how the rich-got-richer nature of schools funded by property taxes left poor kids in communities victimized by redlining. But her platform fails to note that even in states where the difference between rich suburban schools and lower funded urban schools is most pronounced, charter schools are the poorest of these schools.

There is no place in America where charter schools receive the same funding as their district school counterparts, a fact made more acute because charter schools typically pay for their own facilities, which further drives down the amount that can be spent on things like teacher salaries — about which, as a former teacher, the senator apparently cares. If equalization is the goal, the answer should not be to lift funding for one group of poor kids in district schools while sacrificing the rest on an altar of imperfect collectivism.

Perhaps most pernicious of the senator’s proposals is the elimination of federal Charter School Program grants — a program President Obama expanded greatly. These grants are vital for community members, who aren’t deep-pocketed, who lack access to big philanthropy, who only want high-quality alternatives to traditional public schools close to home. Indeed, given the regulatory hurdles, planning time, and facilities challenges most potential charter starters face, the grants aren’t just vital, they’re essential. In killing this program Warren would be — in calculated fashion — retreating on issues that put her on the radar of many regular folks.

A woman whose brand is standing up for the poewrless is, here, comforting the powerful and hindering the needy.

The senator’s education plan features a federal competitive grant program to spur state action on redrawing school district boundaries, which have enforced racial segregation in neighborhoods and public schools. But charter schools, by virtue of many state laws, are already available to students across these lines already. They’re a solution to this issue, not the problem.

And if federal grant programs are an engine of fairness against greedy banking oligarchs in the housing market — the senator wants to expand the federal role in supporting middle- and working-class home ownership as Presidents Clinton and Bush did — how is eliminating that backstop for local educators, instead forcing them to seek capital in the banking sector, either good or intellectually consistent? Far from embracing diversity, if you want to ensure minority leaders and educators — who are routinely frozen out of credit markets — don’t get to start schools, this is exactly how one would do it.

Elizabeth Warren says she wants “all students [to] have access to great public education.” She’ll instead ensure fewer do while swapping schools run by small, nimble groups of educators for those led by large and distant bureaucracies. It’s also hard to ignore the obvious racial implications of this plan to make education great again. If enacted, teachers unions — whose workforces are overwhelmingly white — and white progressive Democrats who oppose charters will be happy. For African American and Hispanic families who support charters a great deal, the opposite will be sharply true.

Bradford is the executive vice president of 50CAN.

Tags: Opinion

Source link
Read also:
Business Insider › Politics › 1 month ago
Sen. Elizabeth Warren is the frontrunner, and along with the advantages that brings she was also the object of some heat tonight in Ohio. Five candidates fighting for their spot in this race have a huge vulnerability to Elizabeth Warren. Sen. Amy...
ABC News › 1 month ago
Elizabeth Warren named the 18 transgender women of color who have been killed this year at the LGBTQ forum in Iowa.
Business Insider › 1 month ago
Color-correcting is a common makeup trick that uses principles from the color wheel to help balance out discoloration like redness, sallowness, and more. The mint-green color in Dr. Jart+ Cicapair Tiger Grass Color Correcting Treatment SPF 30 ($49.95...
Business Insider › 1 month ago
A new report from LeanIn.org and McKinsey found women of color make up just 4% of C-suite executives. Research shows this is just one of many ways work in America is failing women of color, particularly black women and Latina employees. Women of color...
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 1 day ago
You can change the background color on Google Docs in just a few simple steps. You'll be able to pick from a group of preset colors, or you can use an HTML color code to select a specific color or shade. Here's what you'll need to do to change the...
Business Insider › Finance › 6 days ago
Senator Elizabeth Warren is taking her squabble with opposing billionaires to TV by buying ad time for CNBC this week, a campaign aide told CNBC. The video is titled "Elizabeth Warren Stands Up to Billionaires," and includes clips of investor Leon...
Business Insider › Politics › 2 months ago
Who is Elizabeth Warren? Current job: US Senator from Massachusetts. Running for president of the United States as a Democratic candidate. Age: 70 Family: Warren is married to law professor Bruce Mann. She has two children, Amelia Warren Tyagi and...
The Week › 1 month ago
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has more than small donor money in her pocket. After South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg attacked Warren and other candidates for relying on "pocket change" to fund their 2020 campaigns, Warren issued a typically...
Business Insider › Politics › 0 month ago
FEC data show that Elizabeth Warren has more Silicon Valley campaign contributions than other democratic candidates, Bloomberg reported. Warren leads with Silicon Valley donors, followed by Bernie Sanders and Pete Buttigieg. Warren has been the most...
Raw Story › Politics › 2 weeks ago
Elizabeth Warren’s rise in the polls resulted in NBC’s “Saturday Night Live” devoting the cold open sketch the Massachuttes senator. The show imagined Warren answering questions at a town hall in Iowa. SNL’s Warren was energetic, confident...
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google