Bill Taylor’s testimony removes any last plausible line of defense for Trump

The Guardian Opinions 3 weeks ago

On Tuesday, Donald Trump dismissed the impeachment inquiry into his conduct towards Ukraine as a “lynching”. This proved, unsurprisingly, that Trump doesn’t know much about history – for a start, victims of lynching couldn’t look forward to a trial heavily stacked in their favor, which is likely what awaits Trump in the Senate. It also showed that there is no depth to which the president will not stoop in an attempt to distract attention from his wrongdoing.

It was no surprise that Trump wanted to create a distraction on the day that the impeachment inquiry heard its most explosive testimony yet. But we shouldn’t let him. Stunning new details were provided by William B Taylor, the top US diplomat in Ukraine, who the State Department tried to block from testifying before Congress. He went anyway, and what he said provided the most direct evidence yet that Trump ordered military assistance to Ukraine to be withheld until Kiev agreed to take action that would benefit the president’s re-election campaign.

Taylor testified that even though he was the top American representative in Ukraine, he found himself undercut by Trump appointees who ran their own “unofficial” Ukraine policy. One of this latter group, Gordon Sondland, told Taylor that “everything” Ukraine wanted from Washington – including a meeting with Trump and security assistance for its war against Russia – was dependent on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky announcing investigations into Hunter Biden’s business dealings in Ukraine and alleged Ukrainian interference in the 2016 US election.

When Taylor raised concerns over what was happening, he was met with the sort of inversion of truth and of the meaning of the English language which the Trump administration has long practiced. Both Sondland and Trump insisted no “quid pro quo” was expected of Ukraine – before spelling out precisely the actions Kiev would have to take in order to receive security assistance. According to Taylor, Sondland even told him that Trump “is a businessman” and that businessmen always make sure to collect what they are owed.

Taylor also said that Zelensky was being pressured to give a statement about opening the investigations on CNN, making clear that the aim was to influence US public opinion rather than to actually tackle corruption in Ukraine. Officials in Kiev certainly understood the message they were receiving, and were deeply disturbed by the contents. According to Taylor, Zelensky’s national security advisor “conveyed to me that President Zelensky did not want to be used as a pawn in a US re-election campaign.”

Rather than denying the facts that Taylor reported, the White House last night dismissed the impeachment inquiry as “a coordinated smear campaign from far-left lawmakers and radical unelected bureaucrats.” But to any reasonable person, Taylor is impossible to dismiss as a partisan hack. A former infantry officer who served in Vietnam, he has worked in both Republican and Democratic administrations, and was first appointed as ambassador to Ukraine by George W Bush. Taylor was critical of aspects of Barack Obama’s policy towards Ukraine, including his administration’s decision not to provide lethal military aid – the same military aid that Trump later announced he would supply and then corruptly withheld.

Taylor’s testimony removes any last plausible line of defense of the president’s conduct. Trump clearly perverted US official diplomacy in pursuit of his own private interests. The “investigations” he pressured Ukraine to open into his political opponents were based on conspiracy theories, meaning the investigations themselves could only be shams. Trump was not asking for an honest investigation of wrongdoing. Instead, he wanted Kiev to make up dirt on his political enemies to substantiate the conspiracy theories he had heard about on TV – or to lose the military aid it needed to survive. It is hard to think of a more shocking misuse of presidential power in foreign affairs.

The most disturbing fact of this whole mess is how close the plot Taylor described came to succeeding. If it hadn’t been for the media, government whistleblowers, and Congress, then the first words the American people heard on the matter might have been President Zelensky appearing on CNN to announce an investigation into Hunter Biden. Instead, these forces came together to provide a vital check on a lawless president, just as they did during Watergate.

The work isn’t yet done. Republicans are likely to invent new excuses to protect the president. But support for removing Trump from office continues to rise, portending a difficult 2020 election both for the president and the Republican senators who continue to defend him. The idea that impeaching Trump was a political mistake, fashionable just weeks ago, looks misplaced in light of everything we have learned since. Impeachment, if pursued wisely, can actually be used to build a case for removing Trump and his protectors at the ballot box.

America deserves a president who doesn’t use his office for personal enrichment and gain at the expense of the public good. It also deserves a president who has enough historical and moral sensibility not to describe his own richly-deserved problems as a “lynching”. Thanks in part to the unfolding impeachment inquiry, it might soon have one.

  • Andy Gawthorpe is a Lecturer in History and International Studies at Leiden University in The Netherlands


Source link
Read also:
Raw Story › 6 days ago
A transcript of ambassador Bill Taylor’s explosive testimony about President Donald Trump’s efforts to pressure the Ukrainian government to investigate former Vice President Joe Biden has been released. In the testimony, Taylor recounted how he was...
Raw Story › 2 weeks ago
Republican sources speaking to CNN say that diplomat Bill Taylor’s closed-door testimony is “reverberating” throughout Capitol Hill and is a “game changer.” CNN reports that at least one GOP source says that Taylor’s testimony “points to...
NBC News › Politics › 57 minutes ago
Nicolle Wallace: Bill Taylor's bombshell testimony draws direct line to Trump
The Hill › 6 days ago
House Democrats on Wednesday released the transcript of Bill Taylor's closed-door testimony in the impeachment probe into President Trump.Taylor, the top U.S. diplomat in Ukraine, was the first official to testify...
Raw Story › 1 hour ago
Ambassador Bill Taylor on Wednesday dropped a new bombshell during impeachment hearings in the House of Representatives. During his testimony, Taylor revealed one of his aides had overheard a conversation between President Donald Trump and European...
Raw Story › 3 weeks ago
The second-ranking Republican senator sounded an alarm over testimony by the former Ukraine ambassador. GOP Whip John Thune (R-SD) reacted to testimony Tuesday by veteran diplomat Bill Taylor, who told lawmakers that President Donald Trump directed...
Reuters › 1 month ago
The scenario of Britain leaving the European Union without a deal is the most plausible outcome, France's foreign minister said on Tuesday.
CNN › Politics › 2 weeks ago
The opening statement of Bill Taylor, the top US diplomat in Ukraine, is "reverberating" on Capitol Hill among Republicans, according to GOP Hill sources, who told CNN that Taylor's testimony is a game changer in the impeachment inquiry into President...
Business Insider › Politics › 6 days ago
House investigators released the transcript of the testimony of the acting US ambassador to Ukraine, Bill Taylor, on Wednesday. Taylor, a Vietnam War veteran and career diplomat with a distinguished record of service, provided one of the most damning...
Alternet › 34 minutes ago
Ambassador Bill Taylor on Wednesday dropped a new bombshell during impeachment hearings in the House of Representatives. During his testimony, Taylor revealed one of his aides had overheard a conversation…
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR