The horrendous message behind Trump's 'lynching' tweet

CNN Opinions 2 weeks ago

CNN's Jeffrey Toobin excoriates President Trump's tweet where he compares the impeachment inquiry to lynching.

One hundred years ago this September, a white mob in Omaha, Nebraska, set the local county courthouse ablaze to force authorities to turn over a black man named Will Brown. The vigilantes strung the prisoner from a telephone pole, riddled his body with hundreds of bullets, and dragged his corpse behind an automobile for several blocks. After dousing Brown's corpse in lantern oil, the mob set him on fire.

Will Brown was a lynching victim.

    President Trump is not.

    In a Tuesday morning tweet, the President of the United States likened the House impeachment inquiry against him to a "lynching." He also bemoaned what he called the lack of "due process or fairness or any legal rights"-- an unwitting but accurate allusion to hundreds of lynching victims, like Will Brown, seized by mobs unwilling to wait for a jury's verdict to render their own brutal judgment.

    The President's invocation of lynching defiles the memory of the thousands of documented victims, overwhelmingly African American, murdered by mobs, but it also serves a political function more potent than blind racial antagonism. For a hard core of Trump supporters, analogies to white supremacist atrocities reinforce the conviction that they are victims, too.

    This is a rhetoric with a history, and it serves as a reminder that what words mean matters to our past and present.

    Trump is not the first to deploy the lynching label to discredit political opponents or processes. The tweet appeared as he implored Republicans to rally in his defense, much as they did in 1991, when Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas survived a confirmation process he decried as a "high-tech lynching."

    The twisted invocation of past racial wrongs extends beyond lynching comparisons, as evinced by the President's affinity for tweets by those who espouse "white genocide" conspiracy theories, and his political appointees, like HUD Secretary Ben Carson, who in 2011 compared the Affordable Care Act to antebellum enslavement.

    Indeed, this rhetorical tradition stretches back to political demagogues of past generations, like conservatives in the 1930s who compared Social Security to slavery or opponents of the nation's first anti-lynching legislation who accused civil rights supporters of "lynching the Constitution."

    Rhetoric of the kind that the President deployed on Twitter undercuts an honest reckoning with America's past by muddying the meaning of terms that help us name and navigate a bloody legacy of racial violence.

    By co-opting the word "lynching" to mean anything unpleasant or objectionable, and deploying the term for political expediency or more dangerous ends, the speaker, writer, or, in this case, the tweeter, diminishes lynching's power in American history.

    Worse still, claiming the identity of a lynching victim is an outrageous distraction from and diminishment of the suffering of the many thousands who died at the hands of bloodthirsty mobs—spurred, in many cases, by the racial demagogues of that day. We honor their memory by saying their names; we debase their brutal, shameful treatment by claiming to be them to glibly score rhetorical points.

    As other commentators have noted, the President's lynching tweet follows in a long line of racist remarks, but this particular comment does something additional: it taps into a broader vein of racial grievance and resentment.

      Like the Tennessee county commissioner who, just yesterday, ended a rant against Democratic presidential contenders by declaring that "a white male in this country has very few rights and they're getting took more every day," the President understands the power of flipping the script of a racial past he may have more of a feel for than he knows.

      But while the President and some diehard supporters trade in claims that they are America's true victims, their rhetoric suggests another possibility—a tacit admission, perhaps, that there is no worse fate in American history than being treated like black folk.


      Source link
      Read also:
      CNN › Politics › 2 weeks ago
      House Republican leader Kevin McCarthy on Tuesday did not endorse President Donald Trump's comparison of the impeachment inquiry to a "lynching," saying, "That's not the language I would use" and "I don't agree with that language, it's pretty simple."
      The Week › 2 weeks ago
      President Trump is earning pushback from some Republicans for comparing the House of Representatives' impeachment inquiry to a "lynching," but not from Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.). Trump declared the inquiry a "lynching" in a tweet Tuesday morning...
      Sputnik International › 2 weeks ago
      A large number of Democratic lawmakers were filmed repeatedly using the word “lynching” two decades ago. So why is Trump’s “lynching” tweet is so outrageous now?
      CNN › 2 weeks ago
      Step outside the politics for a moment. The act of lynching was, and remains, a horrific reality.
      Business Insider › Politics › 2 weeks ago
      Several Republican lawmakers are either defending, refusing to condemn, or simply declining to comment on President Donald Trump's Tuesday tweet comparing the ongoing impeachment inquiry into him to a lynching. Trump's tweet was immediately denounced...
      Raw Story › 2 weeks ago
      Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC) on Tuesday schooled President Donald Trump for accusing House Democrats of “lynching” him through their impeachment inquiry. After CNN host John Berman read Clyburn the president’s tweet and asked him for his opinion...
      Raw Story › 2 weeks ago
      Princeton University History Professor Kevin Kruse on Tuesday delivered a thorough takedown of President Donald Trump’s claim that House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry represents a “lynching.” In calling the tweet “twelve different kinds of...
      CBS Local › Politics › 2 weeks ago
      Former Maryland Republican Lieutenant Governor Michael Steele blasted President Donald Trump's tweet comparing the impeachment process to a lynching.
      ABC News › 2 weeks ago
      Rep. Karen Bass, D-Calif., condemned Trump's tweet comparing the impeachment probe to a lynching.
      NBC News › 2 weeks ago
      Trump compares impeachment inquiry to 'a lynching' in morning tweet
      Sign In

      Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

      Continue with Google
      OR