Minister ignores expert advice, gives North East Link the green light

The $15.8 billion North East Link has got the Planning Minister's tick of approval, after he dismissed many of the findings of an independent panel who had spent weeks assessing the project's effects on the environment.

Planning Minister Richard Wynne has signed off on what will be Victoria's most expensive road, despite its impact on 53 hectares of open space, the loss of nearly 800 jobs and a "protracted construction period" that will be so unpleasant that more homes may need to be bought.

The North East Link could look a lot like this.

Mr Wynn found that the "project’s adverse environmental effects can be appropriately managed and will be acceptable considering the project’s significant benefits".

The minister was responding to findings by an independent panel that oversaw nine weeks of hearings into the environmental impacts of the new toll road.

In a 500-page report released on Thursday morning, the Independent Advisory Council has sharply criticised the project's impact on the liveability of tens of thousands of people who live along the sensitive corridor in Melbourne's north-east.

"This project needs to successfully resolve the tension between road functionality, infrastructure and safety with community liveability, landscape character and economic prosperity in this sensitive corridor," the report stated. "It has not yet struck this balance."

Mr Wynne has rejected three key recommendations put forward by the panel, citing cost and the need for more land acquisitions.

These recommendations were to extend the length of the tunnel to minimise impacts on jobs, avoid surface works at Simpsons Barracks to reduce any impacts on trees and wildlife and move the launch site for the massive tunnel boring machines away from residential Borlase Reserve to reduce impacts on the people who live there.

“I am also not satisfied that the overall environmental outcomes of the project would be improved if these aspects are implemented," the minister found.

The independent panel said that the twin tunnels built beneath Bulleen must be extended further northwards to Grimshaw Street in Watsonia to avoid negative impacts that five years of construction would have on businesses in the suburb.

Planning Minister Richard Wynne.

This would help balance out the "unprecedented" destruction of local jobs needed to build the toll road, with the project set to acquire 102 businesses in the Bulleen Industrial Precinct, the panel stated.

The advisory council says that considering "the unprecedented scale of the loss of a whole industrial area and the particular characteristics of the industrial precinct, it is incumbent on the proponent and state to mitigate this impact to the maximum extent possible".

More to come...

Source link
Read also:
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 2 days ago
You can turn on the keyboard light on your Mac computer so that it's easy to see the keys even in low-light conditions. To adjust the brightness of the keyboard light on your Mac, use the F5 and F6 keys. You can also set up your keyboard light to...
Business Insider › 1 week ago
Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi was asked about the best advice he ever received, and the best advice he has for young people, at a luncheon this week. The Iranian-American executive said his best advice came from Herbert Allen of Allen & Company, which is...
USA Today › 1 month ago
All advice is not good advice...some of it is just plain bad...And in those times of receiving bad advice, you have to ask yourself… ‘but did it make me laugh?’
CNN › Politics › 1 month ago
President Donald Trump intervened Friday in three high profile military criminal cases involving war crimes, a decision that ignored the strong advice of Secretary of Defense Mark Esper and many of his most senior commanders.
Business Insider › Technology › 2 months ago
The JBL Link Bar ($400) isn't just a soundbar, streaming device, or smart speaker — it's all three in one. The device offers Android TV and Google Assistant built right into it, along with a decent design. While it's not perfect, the Link Bar is...
Business Insider › Entertainment › 1 week ago
A major update to Nintendo's "Super Mario Maker 2" will add a special item that transforms Mario into Link, the hero from "The Legend of Zelda." When Mario picks up Link's Master Sword, he'll also be able to use a bow & arrow, a shield, bombs, and a...
Daily Mail Online › 1 month ago
A study involving more than 15,000 Americans involved four waves of interviews throughout their life. It was used to assess any link between violence and gaming and other possible causes of the link.
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 2 weeks ago
You can put a link in your Instagram bio to a personal website or other site you want your followers to visit. Anyone who visits your Instagram profile can see and click on the link placed in your profile even if your photos are private. Links in...
The New York Times › Finance › 1 week ago
The LF Woodford Income Focus Fund will remain suspended while its authorised corporate director Link Fund Solutions reviews two options for it, Link told investors on Wednesday.
Business Insider › Lifestyle › 2 months ago
It's possible to share a YouTube playlist in two different ways. You can share a YouTube playlist by sending a link to view, or you can also share a YouTube playlist by sending a link to collaborate. When you share a YouTube playlist for collaboration...
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google