Scotland stops treating under-12s as criminals but is urged to do more

The Guardian 2 weeks ago

Scotland is to stop treating children under 12 as offenders later this month after the Scottish parliament voted earlier this year to raise the age of criminal responsibility from eight.

The Scottish children’s commissioner, however, has criticised the measure as inadequate and urged ministers in Edinburgh to revisit the decision and raise the minimum age to 14.

Bruce Adamson said he had repeatedly urged Scottish government ministers to change their minds and follow expert advice from human rights bodies, including the UN, that 12 was too low.

“A country like Scotland, with all its advantages, is really out of step,” he said. “This I see as a failure. My position is we are in breach of our obligations and Scottish ministers should be bringing this back before parliament right now.”

The devolved government, which has full control over criminal justice in Scotland, won support for moving the age to 12 at Holyrood after arguing it marked a significant cultural shift.

A Scottish government spokeswoman said the reform would have a significant impact without further changes. “Scotland is leading the way in the UK and will make a real difference in children’s lives with this ground-breaking, progressive and child-centred age of criminal responsibility and victims getting the support they need.”

Children under 16 who commit offences in Scotland are very rarely prosecuted in the criminal courts system. They are referred instead to the children’s hearings system, normally by the police and often with the involvement of the prosecution service.

Unlike youth courts, its cases are judged by lay volunteers who take a welfare-based approach designed to investigate the causes of a child’s behaviour, which can lead to extra school or social work resources for the child.

The Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act will not come fully into force until late 2020, but the referral of under-12s to a children’s panel for alleged offences will end in late November this year. Scotland stopped prosecuting children under 12 through the courts in 2011.

Adamson and bodies such as the Council of Europe, a civil rights body that runs the European court of human rights, argue this still means children over 12 can have an offence on their record, and can have contact with the police and procurator fiscal service.

He said the reform would affect only a handful of children. The latest data shows 94 children under 12 were reported for offences last year, 3.3% of the 2,824 children reported for offences, compared with 711 children aged 12 and 13, or 25% of the total.

The UN children’s committee and the Council of Europe had both advised the Scottish government and parliament that it would be preferable to aim for 15 or 16, with 14 seen as a minimum age of responsibility. Children’s brains cannot process risk or understand consequences in the way an adult’s can, Adamson said.

“This is totally out of step with where Scotland sees itself in terms of human rights and the international community,” he said. “The domestic and global evidence was so clear this was the right thing to do, but yet the government was unmoved.”

A Scottish government spokeswoman said an advisory group was being set up to oversee further reforms. Adamson said the commitment to review the new threshold after it had been in force for three years was too long to wait.

The spokeswoman said attempts by the Liberal Democrats and Scottish Greens to increase the age to 14 or 16 when the bill was being debated at Holyrood had been defeated by a margin of 10 to one.

“This clear consensus means it would not be appropriate now to go back on the pledges made in parliamentary debate and fail to conduct a review that ministers explicitly committed to during the passage of the bill,” she said.

Tags: Society

Source link
Read also:
Express › 3 weeks ago
A BAN on children under 12 heading the ball is to be considered by the Scottish Football Association after a report linked dementia and football.
The Independent › Sports › 1 month ago
Scotland 34-0 Samoa: Scotland kept Samoa scoreless and secured a bonus point in Kobe
Evening Standard › Politics › 2 weeks ago
Nicola Sturgeon called on voters to put "Scotland's future into Scotland's hands" and back her vision for independence.
CBS Local › Sports › 1 week ago
The Sooners scraped past Iowa State to win by one point and now the'll head to Waco to face Baylor -- the Big 12's only undefeated team.
Chicago Tribune › 0 month ago
A review by a former federal judge of how Chicago police conduct street stops has found a troubling trend -- supervisors assisting officers in revising their reports, sometimes multiple times, to make it appear the stops were constitutional.
The Sun › Politics › 5 days ago
THOUSANDS of extra foreign criminals would end up in Britain’s prisons under Labour, it was claimed yesterday. They would flood here from the EU if Jeremy Corbyn sticks to his open-door immigration policy. It will bring hundreds of thousands more...
Express › Politics › 1 month ago
FOREIGN criminals who flout deportation orders to sneak back into the UK will face jail terms of at least two years under a law-and-order crackdown to be announced in the Queen’s Speech today.
Express › 1 month ago
VIOLENT criminals are being let back on the streets because police take too long to charge them, it was revealed yesterday. Suspects are “released under investigation” (RUI), even when accused of serious crimes including murder, rape, robbery and...
RT › 1 week ago
In the last-ditch attempt to save several residential areas from getting a “severe ghetto” label, which leads to their demolition under a controversial law, Danish city of Odense offered to pay local criminals to move out. Read Full Article at RT.com
The Guardian › Sports › 1 month ago
Scotland must win to remain in with a chance of reaching the World Cup quarter-finals but will face angry opponentsThe Test has not started yet, but Scotland may have already made their first mistake. Three days ago, Greig Laidlaw decided to weigh in...
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR