The Other Cost Of School Choice

Forbes 1 month ago
Cookie Monster is pictured in the Washington Post Food Lab with a recipe from his new book, ″The Joy of Cookies.″
C is for cookie, that's good enough for me. (Photo by Sarah L. Voisin/The Washington Post via Getty Images)

When we discuss the cost of school choice–charters, vouchers, and even homeschooling–we usually focus on the economic impact, the loss of local control, or the policy impact on educational institutions. But on the classroom level, there is another real impact.

Robert Pondiscio touches on it in his new book about Success Academy charters schools, How The Other Half Learns:

“The most common objection to charter schools and publicly financed charter school initiatives is that schools of choice ‘siphon resources away’ from traditional public schools. One such ‘resource’ is engaged and invested parents.”

And, one might add, engaged and invested students. Every classroom culture is shaped not just by teachers and building administration, but by the students in the classroom. Students can have a huge effect on the tone of the classroom–is there a steady pressure to achieve, or is acting smart just not cool? Particularly in high school, students learn about peer effects, about how to lead and how to elevate leaders. Strong students can raise a class’s achievement level in ways that a teacher can not.

Most of us have stories. I learned to play trombone in high school in large part from trying to keep pace with the upperclassman who was my section leader. For four years, everyone in my core classes chased the two most intelligent, hardworking women in our grade. As a high school teacher, I saw the same effect over and over again. I could lay out expectations and standards and rubrics, but it is students (and sometimes by extension, their parents) who will answer the question, “How seriously should we take any of this?” That leadership will come from the strong students in the room. There are few things as exhilarating as teaching a class led by a core group of students whose attitude is, “You just teach as fast and far as you can, because we want to see it all, and we will keep pace with you every step of the way, and so will the rest of these students. Right?”

But what if those leaders aren’t there? I’ve taught those classes, too. You make your best pitch and the students look around and conclude that nobody else is working all that hard, so they’ll just take it easy, too. (”Mr. Greene, I’m not an over-achiever or an under-achiever,” a student once told me. “I’m an even-achiever.”) It is a huge challenge to light a fire under a room full of Cookie Monster students.

When stronger, more committed students leave a school, they leave that school with a bit less student leadership, a bit less positive peer effect. Their choice costs their former school something in the school culture and environment. That becomes more troubling when the strong student leaves for a school that doesn’t offer any real benefits above and beyond the original public school.

The policy implications of peer effects are many. Can we even hope to measure these peer effects in any meaningful way, or will researchers just resort to using standardized test scores? If we can identify them, should we attempt to distribute “good” students evenly across the system? And how wildly inappropriate is it to treat students as a school resource rather than individuals working on educational goals of their own?

This is a tension that’s almost impossible to resolve. It is hard to argue that a strong student’s family should keep her in the public school to serve a greater good, yet it seems clear that should she go to a charter, a private school, even a magnet or home school, there is a cost to the students who stay. It’s a personal choice, but it has more than personal consequences, and they are hard to discuss in an age in which we have lost the language of civic obligation. But at a minimum, we should acknowledge that there is a cost here, and somebody–either the school or the student or, in the case of students who choose a school no better than their old one, both–is going to pay it.


Source link
Read also:
New York Post › Opinions › 4 days ago
Elizabeth Warren proudly opposes school choice — for your kids. She apparently could afford to take her own son out of the public-school system and enroll him in a private school, yet her education policies would deny that choice to less wealthy...
The Guardian › Lifestyle › 1 month ago
In some parts of rural Suffolk children on one side of the road pay £750 for school travel – while neighbours go freeParental choice now depends on ability to pay in some rural areas, where a new school bus policy to cut costs is splitting families...
USA Today › Lifestyle › 1 month ago
In rural parts of the South, school choice has long been linked to private segregation academies opened for white families fleeing desegregation.
Cleveland › 6 days ago
The Cleveland school board discussed closing Collinwood High School and other district schools Wednesday, but still differ on whether merge that school into Glenville High and on whether to close the specialized New Tech West High School
Business Insider › Entertainment › 3 weeks ago
On Tuesday, Disney CEO Bob Iger said that the upcoming Disney Plus series, "The Mandalorian," cost around $100 million to make. At eight episodes in length, that would put each episode's cost at around $12.5 million. It's less than the reported $25...
Chicago Tribune › 1 week ago
Next school year, Wilmette School District 39 will offer a full day kindergarten program at an additional cost.
Raw Story › Politics › 2 weeks ago
Former FBI Director James Comey said there was “no choice” but impeachment during an interview at Politicon with MSNBC’s Nicolle Wallace. “The House has no choice but to pursue an impeachment inquiry. All I know about the facts are coming from...
Washington Examiner › Entertainment › 1 month ago
The Critics Choice Association announced its nominees for their fourth annual Critics' Choice Documentary Awards, which includes films by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and former President Barack Obama.
Fox News › Politics › 1 week ago
2020 Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang pushed for ranked-choice voting in a tweet Tuesday as New York City voters are deciding on a potential change to the city's constitution that would incorporate ranked-choice ballots in primary and...
Forbes › 1 month ago
A child unable to get a better education, especially when it is there for the taking, is heartbreaking. School choice is key to ending that pain.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google
OR