MI5 unlawfully authorised informants to commit serious criminal offences, potentially including murder, kidnap and torture, for decades, a tribunal has heard.
Four human rights organisations are taking legal action against the government over a policy they claim “purports to permit (MI5) agents to participate in crime” and effectively “immunises criminal conduct from prosecution”.
The groups argue the practical effect of the policy – which they say “has been in place since at least the 1990s” and was “kept secret for decades” – is “for the executive to grant itself the power, in secret, to dispense with the criminal law enacted by parliament”.
At the start of a four-day hearing in London on Tuesday, Ben Jaffey QC said “the Security Service (MI5) are permitted under the policy to ‘authorise’ criminal conduct for a variety of purposes including any national security purpose, or maintaining the economic well-being of the United Kingdom”.
He added that “the agents in question are not officers of the Security Service, but they are recruited and given directions by MI5”.
However, he said those MI5 officers could become criminally liable as an accessory.
Mr Jaffey said the issues raised by the case are “not hypothetical”, submitting “in the past, authorisation of agent participation in criminality appears to have led to grave breaches of fundamental rights”.
He pointed to the 1989 murder of Belfast solicitor Pat Finucane, an attack later found to have involved collusion with the state, and the case of Freddie Scappaticci, “who is alleged to have been a senior member of the IRA and a security service agent working under the codename ‘Stakeknife”’.
Mr Jaffey told the tribunal that the government had “refused” to confirm that such serious criminal offences “could never be lawfully sanctioned under their policy”.
Sir James Eadie QC, representing the government, said in written submissions it would be “impossible” for MI5 to operate without covert human intelligence sources (CHIS) “also known as agents”.
“They are indispensable to the work of the Security Service, and thus to its ability to protect the public from the range of current threats, notably from terrorist attackers,” Sir James submitted.
He added: “Given the covert nature of CHIS, and given the types of person with whom and entities with which they have relationships, they need to behave in certain ways and participate in certain activities.”
Sir James said that “this behaviour by CHIS is an inevitable and necessary part of their ability to function as providers of vital life-saving intelligence, and in order to seek to protect their own lives and safety from the hostile, dangerous actors on whom they are providing intelligence”.
He submitted that MI5 “does not, and does not purport to, confer immunity from criminal liability”, adding: “A prosecution remains possible.”
Sir James concluded that “the underlying conduct – namely the participation in possible criminal activities by agents – was widely known and entirely obvious”, describing it as “an unavoidable part of their maintaining their cover and acquiring vital intelligence”.
The tribunal, led by IPT president Lord Justice Singh, is due to hear submissions over four days and is expected to reserve its judgment.
Friday was a special day for Teen Mom 2 star Jade Cline as she announced she was officially a licensed cosmetologist. The reality show star took to her social media accounts to share the exciting news with her fans. “Ya girl is a licensed...
Lesley Stahl reports on law enforcement's controversial use of young confidential informants in the war on drugs, some of whose cases ended tragically; endangered bonobos live in female-dominated groups and do not kill each other -- preferring to make...
Robert Ehrhardt, of Winthrop Harbor, is scheduled to be sentenced Jan. 30 after being found guilty of animal torture in a one-day bench trial Monday in Lake County Circuit Court. He was charged with three counts of animal torture and convicted on one...
Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance’s probe into President Trump’s finances is relying on “confidential informants,” his lawyers revealed in a new filing Tuesday. “The criminal investigation is proceeding based upon information derived...
Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance revealed Tuesday that “confidential informants” are part of his probe involving President Trump’s tax returns.
Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.
Continue with GoogleContinue with FacebookContinue with Twitter