Analysis Of Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s Cryptocurrency Testimony Before Congressional Hearing

Forbes Finance 3 weeks ago
Mark Zuckerberg
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg makes rounds of meeting with senators in September. On October 23 he'll ... [+] address congress directly related to cryptocurrency.

At 10 am ET this morning, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg is scheduled to testify before the United States House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services about his role in developing libra, a cryptocurrency backed by a basket of stable international assets and designed to be spendable anywhere in the world. But as is typical, the entire written testimony has been released in advance of the hearing so members of congress and others can prepare their line of questioning.

While state governments and the central banks that print those states’ national currencies grapple with what it would mean to have a global currency backed by their own assets, in some ways Zuckerberg’s comments are disappointingly predictable. But as three new bills were introduced to congress in the days leading up to the testimony, undoubtedly it will be the congressional grilling that follows the testimony that provides the most insight into Facebook’s plans and Zuckerberg’s mindset.

The testimony is broken down into five sections: introduction, a summary of the Libra Project, combating discrimination, a commitment to diversity, and a conclusion.

The introduction is interesting for three reasons. First, Zuckerberg plans to position Libra on the global context as a reaction to China’s plans to release a similar cryptocurrency spendable anywhere in the world, and distributed via a consortium of state-owned companies. While Facebook has previously emphasized that the cryptocurrency would be backed by a basket of international currencies, perhaps giving a broader group of people a sense of investment in the technology, today Zuckerberg will use the political undertones and his audience of U.S. elected officials to refocus the project on it’s American roots.

“Libra will be backed mostly by dollars and I believe it will extend America’s financial leadership,” Zuckerberg will say, according to the prepared notes. “As well as our democratic values and oversight around the world. If America doesn’t innovate, our financial leadership is not guaranteed.”

The introduction is also notable in that it foreshadows an surprising amount of attention on questions of diversity and civil rights, topics he’s previously addressed in front of congress, but which only tangentially have to do with the cryptocurrency, which is being designed with un-banked people typically consisting of underrepresented groups. Zuckerberg plans to wrap up his address with what appears to pander to the religious inclinations of some elected officials and U.S. voters. “I feel blessed to be in a position where we can make a difference in people’s lives,” his prepared remarks say.

The second section of Zuckerberg’s remarks to congress largely rehash the already well-known definition of the Libra Association founded by Facebook, the cryptocurrency, and Facebook’s Calibra wallet for storing the cryptocurrency with one small change. Since Facebook’s head of cryptocurrency, David Marcus testified before congress in July, four U.S. lawmakers sent a letter to association members asking them not to participate in the group, which was followed by an exodus of ever major financial player in the group, including PayPal, MasterCard and Visa. Not all elected officials, responded so harshly, with U.S. Senator Mike Rounds of South calling his colleagues’ “ominous tone” “disappointing, and expressing support for the financial innovation. This section will conclude by distinguishing Facebook’s version of a cryptocurrency wallet for storing libra, called Calibra, from the cryptocurrency, and to clarify Facebook’s intention not to sell data about Calibra wallet users to third parties. The section also reiterates Facebook’s desire to position libra as a U.S. tool for global financial competition. If America doesn’t lead on this, others will,” the submitted comments read. “Foreign companies or countries may act without the same regulatory oversight or commitment to transparency.”

Sections three and four really address the same subject of combating discrimination. Reading between the lines however, the comments could serve two goals related to libra. First, they focus on some of the positive changes Facebook has made recently, including the establishment of a civil rights task force, which could leave a good taste in congress members mouths while so much negative news about Facebook fills the headlines. Second, the groups of people typically addressed in these civil rights campaigns, women and other underrepresented groups, are among the same people Facebook has publicly identified as its target user for the cryptocurrency: the under-banked.

The conclusion is largely aimed at reiterating Facebook’s previously stated intention of not launching without regulatory support, which in increasingly looking like a tough sell. As of early last week there were 21 bills relating to blockchain in various stages of passing through congressional review. But on Friday, October 19, three new bills were introduced aimed at undermining Facebook’s efforts. An updated version of the “Keeping Big Tech Out of Finance Act”, appears to be largely targeted at keeping Facebook away from cryptocurrency, according to Jason Bret, CEO of the Value Technology advocacy group. The “Stablecoins are Securities” bill could have far-reaching implications to companies like Gemini, Circle and Coinbase, which have already created stablecoins similar to libra but backed by different assets. The “To Prohibit The Listing of Certain Securities,” appears to seek to prevent stablecoins like libra from entering the capital markets space, according to Brett.

“As Congress attempts to reign in Libra from its perceived impact to the strength of the U.S. dollar, policymakers are creating broad measures that has an impact beyond Facebook,” says Brett. “If the three bills were actually passed, no Big Tech company could offer a cryptocurrency, all stablecoins will be treated as securities, and any company or its officers profiting from a stablecoin will face being delisted from a stock exchange.”

Tags: Money

Source link
Read also:
Business Insider › Politics › 1 month ago
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg will testify before congress at an October 23 hearing, Rep. Maxine Waters announced Wednesday. Zuckerberg will likely face questions about Libra, Facebook's cryptocurrency venture that has already drawn scrutiny from...
The Daily Beast › Technology › 3 weeks ago
MANDEL NGAN / AFPFacebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg testified Wednesday before the House Financial Services Committee in a hearing about the company’s imperiled cryptocurrency project Libra. In the hearing, Zuckerberg made efforts to distance Facebook from...
Axios › Technology › 1 month ago
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg will testify before the House Financial Services Committee on Oct. 23 as part of a hearing titled, "An Examination of Facebook and Its Impact on the Financial Services and Housing Sectors."Why it matters: Libra, Facebook's...
The Hill › Politics › 1 month ago
A House panel is seeking testimony from Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg on the launch of Facebook's cryptocurrency, dubbed Libra....
UPI › 1 month ago
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg will testify before the House about the company's Libra cryptocurrency and digital wallet Calibra in October.
Business Insider › Finance › 1 month ago
Apple does not plan to create a cryptocurrency any time soon, CEO Tim Cook said. Facebook has announced plans to release a cryptocurrency in June 2020. Cook, taking a not-so-subtle shot at Facebook, said he thinks making a cryptocurrency is an...
Business Insider › Politics › 0 month ago
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg will testify before the House Financial Services Committee on October 23 to answer questions about his company's impact on the financial services and housing sectors. The committee will likely ask Zuckerberg about the...
Business Insider › Finance › 3 weeks ago
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey didn't hold back his thoughts on Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg during a Twitter event on Thursday. Dorsey took issue with Zuckerberg's comments on free speech. The Twitter cofounder and CEO also slammed Zuckerberg for claiming...
Washington Examiner › Finance › 1 month ago
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg will testify before the House Financial Services Committee on Oct. 23 to discuss Facebook’s impact on the finance and housing industries.
Breitbart › Technology › 3 weeks ago
In a hearing today before the House Financial Services Committee, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg stated he "didn't know" if his company's new Libra cryptocurrency would work.
Sign In

Sign in to follow sources and tags you love, and get personalized stories.

Continue with Google